When you need a website, you have three main paths: build it yourself on a platform like Wix or Squarespace, hire a freelance web designer, or work with a web design agency or studio. Each can be the right choice. Each can also be the wrong one.
This guide compares all three honestly, including where an agency like ours isn’t the best fit, so you can choose what suits your Toronto business right now.
The Quick Comparison
| DIY (Wix, Squarespace) | Freelancer | Agency / Studio | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lowest | Low to medium | Medium to high |
| Your time required | High | Medium | Low |
| Design quality | Template-based | Varies widely | Usually consistent |
| Custom features | Limited | Depends on skills | Broad |
| SEO | Basic, DIY | Varies | Usually built in |
| Support after launch | Platform help desk | Depends on availability | Structured plans |
| Best for | Testing an idea, tiny budgets | Simple sites, clear scope | Growth-focused businesses |
Option 1: DIY with Wix, Squarespace or Similar
Pros
- Low monthly cost and no big upfront payment
- Full control. You can change things whenever you like
- Quick to get something online
Cons
- You do all the work: content, design choices, SEO, troubleshooting
- Templates make it harder to stand out
- Advanced features (complex booking, integrations, custom e-commerce) can be limited or costly
- Moving to another platform later can be difficult
Best for: brand-new businesses testing an idea, or owners who enjoy hands-on work and have the time. If you’re weighing free options, read Can You Get a Free Website in Toronto?
Option 2: Hire a Freelance Web Designer
Pros
- Often lower cost than an agency
- Direct relationship with the person doing the work
- Great freelancers can produce excellent, custom work
Cons
- Quality and reliability vary a lot
- One person can’t be an expert in everything: design, development, SEO, copywriting
- If they get sick, busy or move on, your project or support can stall
- Less formal process, so scope and timelines can drift
Best for: simple sites with a clear scope, where you’ve seen the freelancer’s past work and checked references.
Tips for hiring a freelancer
- Ask for live links to past work, not just screenshots
- Get a written scope and timeline
- Make sure the domain and all accounts are in your name
- Agree on what happens after launch
Option 3: Work with a Web Design Agency or Studio
Pros
- A team covers design, development, SEO and support
- Structured process with defined milestones
- Can handle complex features: e-commerce, integrations, custom software
- Continuity. The business doesn’t depend on one person
- Ongoing maintenance and growth support
Cons
- Higher upfront cost than DIY or most freelancers
- Large agencies can feel impersonal, and smaller clients may get less attention
- Some agencies push bigger packages than you need
Best for: businesses that rely on their website for leads or sales, need custom functionality, or want someone accountable for results over time.
What About a Small Studio?
Studios like Speck Creations sit between a solo freelancer and a large agency. You get a team and a defined process, but you still work directly with the people building your site. Our starting prices reflect that: custom websites from $1,500, e-commerce from $3,000. Our Toronto website cost guide has the full breakdown.
How to Decide: Five Questions
- What should the website do? An online business card and a lead-generating sales tool are very different projects.
- How much time do you have? DIY trades money for hours.
- Do you need custom features? Booking, e-commerce, integrations and portals favour professionals.
- Who will maintain it? Updates, security and fixes don’t stop after launch.
- What’s a new customer worth to you? If one extra client a month covers the cost, a professional site often pays for itself.
Our Honest Recommendation
- Just starting, very tight budget, mostly need contact info online? Start with DIY.
- Simple site, a trusted freelancer you’ve vetted? A freelancer can work well.
- Your website needs to bring in business, or you need more than the basics? Work with a studio or agency.
Whichever route you take, our guide on what to expect when you hire a web development studio will help you ask the right questions.
Not Sure Which Is Right for You?
Tell us about your business and goals. We’ll give you an honest recommendation, even if that means telling you DIY is the better move for now. If we’re a fit, you’ll get a detailed quote within 24 hours.